

Lexile Measure: 420 (What's this?)
Series: Boxcar Children Beginning
Paperback: 144 pages
Publisher: Albert Whitman & Company; Dgs edition (September 1, 2013)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 0807566179
ISBN-13: 978-0807566176
Product Dimensions: 0.5 x 5.2 x 7.5 inches
Shipping Weight: 4 ounces (View shipping rates and policies)
Average Customer Review: 4.6 out of 5 stars See all reviews (58 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #47,356 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #80 in Books > Children's Books > Literature & Fiction > Historical Fiction > United States > 1900s #91 in Books > Children's Books > Geography & Cultures > Where We Live > Farm Life #258 in Books > Children's Books > Growing Up & Facts of Life > Family Life > Parents
Age Range: 7 - 9 years
Grade Level: 2 - 5

Reason for Reading: I am reading and collecting the first 19 original books by Gertrude Chandler Warner. I usually don't read modern prequels or continuations such as this (I didn't go anywhere near the Anne of Green Gables prequel!) but MacLachlan is a widely respected, award winning author whom I've read before so after a little consideration I thought I would give this a go.MacLachlan is a good writer who especially does the historical very well. The year is never given, but going from the first BC book, this must be set in the early 40s. These are "hard times" and the Aldens live a simple life and the book tells the daily life of a simple family. There is slight drama to the plot but mostly it is a series of events that lead up to what the reader knows will be coming, the death of their parents and the turning of the children into orphans. This is all dealt with very gently and "not a big deal". No one should come into this book not having read their share of Boxcar Children Mysteries; this story is not to make one sad as one already knows the grand future of these children. MacLachlan has managed to keep Warner's simple style of writing while maintaining a quality work something she is well known for in her original work.Overall, I didn't really find this story adding anything that needed to be told. It is a simple book, not the beginning of a new series and does not add to the Alden Family canon. I'm sure it will sell well initially, but has nothing to sustain its longevity. A slow, gentle story, without much happening, no mystery and simply a preface to the opening chapter of the original Boxcar Children written in 1942.
What a coincidence! Just recently, my kids and I found a well-read copy of Boxcar Children #2: Surprise Island. They read it again. My daughters are grown, but one said that she always wanted to know what Henry, Jessie, Violet, and Benny did before the first book. Who were their friends? What were their parents like? I always wondered why the Alden kids were so sure that their grandpa wouldn't help them.Then two weeks later, this prequel came to our home. Since she loved the series so much (especially the first book), my daughter still isn't sure, after reading, whether Gertrude Chandler Warner would have agreed with MacLachlan's picture of the Alden's early lives.Since I read the book for the first time, as a mom, I don't have the attachment to the original that my kids do. I think that MacLachlan captured the resourcefulness, the sharing, and fun of the original series. This story presents how their personalities and talents started on Fair Meadow Farm: Jessie's responsible planning, Benny's love of new friends and dogs, Violet's knack with thread and paint, and Henry's love of adventure and leadership.*This book was received for review, this in no way affects my opinion*
The Boxcar Children had always been a large part of my life. From reading one of the first editions at my Grandmother's house to starting my own collection, the Aldens had grown up with me, like they were a part of my family. One of the questions that had always nagged at me was what happened to their parents, their old home? I've read two versions of the first book and neither of them mention what happened to the parents or why they're scared of/despise this Grandfather that they never met. This book satisfies that curiosity.The only problem I have with it is that the writing style is so different from Gertrude Chandler Warner's own style that it's hard to ignore. I'm not saying that its bad, but being a writer myself I can recognize different writing styles and it takes away from the otherwise excellent story. Boxcar Children fans will certainly enjoy learning about how four children came to stand in in front of a bakery and learn about what happened on Fair Meadow Farm and the secret origin of The Boxcar Children.
The original Boxcar Children (book #1) is one of the most beautiful books in all of children's literature. You've got to love Patricia MacLachlan for caring enough about these wonderful characters to go to the trouble and effort to research and write a prequel.One negative: most of the book is about the Alden's relationship with a family who never appears again in their lives (I presume: I've only read Boxcar Children #1.) Although the relationship says alot about the character of their parents, and is a beautiful story in and of itself, it's a bit of a disconnection from the events which matter to the rest of the series (i.e., that the children become orphaned and end up living self-sufficiently in a boxcar in order to keep the family together, out of an orphanage). But MacLachlan stayed true to Gertrude Warner Chandler's voice and vision, and for that she deserves praise.A few reviewers have not liked the fact that the book has a sad ending -- but there is no way around that when the book's primary purpose is to explain how the children came to be orphans. I mean, duh! There is no way to write a prequel which does not end with the death of the parents! What is important is that MacLachlan overall emphasis is not on death but on the type of family life which molded these four children into such wonderful, responsible, loving human beings.Anyway. Only read this book if you loved Boxcar Children #1 and are curious about how one author imagines the backstory. One review complains that this book is not the way to begin the series, and I agree: don't begin your reading of the Boxcar Children with THIS book! If you don't already love and respect these children, you likely will not find this book interesting enough.
The Boxcar Children Beginning: The Aldens of Fair Meadow Farm The Boxcar Children (The Boxcar Children, No. 1) (Boxcar Children Mysteries) The Boxcar Children (The Boxcar Children Mysteries Book 1) The Boxcar Children (Boxcar Children Mysteries) Grave Mercy: His Fair Assassin, Book I (His Fair Assassin Trilogy) Bedtime in the Meadow (Padded Board Books) Butterfly Eyes and Other Secrets of the Meadow Watching Great Meadow: A Place of Joy, A Place of Woe FARM ANIMAL-SERIES BOOK 1: "RUSTY ROOSTER" :Beginner readers early learning (Children's kids eBook)Bedtime Story Picture Book(Preschool 4-8)Animals story ... reader)values (BIG LITTLE FARM) Gertrude Chandler Warner and The Boxcar Children Houseboat Mystery (The Boxcar Children Mysteries #12) Benny Goes Into Business (Boxcar Children Early Reader #5) (Adventures of Benny and Watch) The Mystery at Snowflake Inn (The Boxcar Children Special #3) The Mystery in the Snow (The Boxcar Children, No. 32) Caboose Mystery (Boxcar Children #11) The Mystery of the Mummy's Curse (The Boxcar Children Mysteries #88) The Mystery of the Empty Safe (The Boxcar Children Mysteries Book 75) Mystery Ranch (The Boxcar Children Mysteries #4) Surprise Island (The Boxcar Children Mysteries #2) Mystery Ranch (The Boxcar Children Mysteries Book 4)