

Age Range: 8 - 12 years
Series: Barron's Graphic Classics
Paperback: 48 pages
Publisher: Barron's Educational Series (October 1, 2006)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 0764134914
ISBN-13: 978-0764134913
Product Dimensions: 10.2 x 6.7 x 0.2 inches
Shipping Weight: 1.6 ounces
Average Customer Review: 2.0 out of 5 stars See all reviews (1 customer review)
Best Sellers Rank: #3,125,705 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #26 in Books > Children's Books > Education & Reference > Reference > Citizenship #10048 in Books > Children's Books > Classics #10604 in Books > Children's Books > Comics & Graphic Novels

I collect graphic novels based on classic literature, so I had high hopes for this series of Graphic Classics by Barron's. In addition to Treasure Island, they've also published Dracula, Frankenstein, Kidnapped, Moby-Dick, and Journey to the Center of the Earth (maybe others I'm unaware of too). It's a really cool concept, making comic books out of literature that can otherwise be a bit dry and difficult to get through, especially for teenagers. I'm giving it 2 stars for the idea alone. Unfortunately, Barron's does it very poorly.I was introduced to this series beginning with the Barron's Graphic Classics version of Dracula by Bram Stoker, and while I don't own the other books, I've seen and read them at my local Barnes & Noble. I was highly disappointed when I received my copy of Dracula, and I wanted to be certain that the other books in the series were of similarly poor quality before dismissing the whole series out of hand, so I checked them out in person at my local bookshop. Unfortunately every book I looked at was done in the same style, which I'll describe below. I promptly removed all the others in this series from my wishlist.The problem is that these books are not graphic novels as the term is generally understood, that is, pages consisting of large colorful panels of artwork that tell a story by portraying consecutive images of action, with characters speaking, acting, and moving throughout various background scenes -- in other words, a comic book. The Barron's graphic novels are more like a children's adaptation of novels. They consist of long paragraphs of text with illustrations alongside.
Treasure Island (Barron's Graphic Classics) Graphic Classics Volume 4: H. P. Lovecraft - 2nd Edition (Graphic Classics (Graphic Novels)) Treasure Seekers: 13 Bible lessons for ages 3-12 about the character of God; tropical island theme with island snacks, activities, fully reproducible (13 Week Bible Curriculum) Treasure Island (Sterling Illustrated Classics) Treasure Island Audio Package (Timeless) (Saddleback Classics) Cool Metal Projects: Creative Ways to Upcycle Your Trash Into Treasure (Checkerboard How-To Library: Cool Trash to Treasure (Library)) Hamlet (Barron's Graphic Classics) Treasure Island (Candlewick Illustrated Classic) The Adventure Collection: Treasure Island, The Jungle Book, Gulliver's Travels, White Fang, The Merry Adventures of Robin Treasure Island Treasure Island (The Robert Louis Stevenson Classic) Treasure Island: A BabyLit® Shapes Primer (BabyLit Books) Treasure Island (Dover Thrift Editions) R is for Rhode Island Red: A Rhode Island Alphabet (Discover America State by State) Island: Poetry and History of Chinese Immigrants on Angel Island, 1910-1940 (Naomi B. Pascal Editor's Endowment) Island Passages: An Illustrated History of Jekyll Island, Georgia Acadia: The Complete Guide: Acadia National Park & Mount Desert Island (Acadia the Complete Guide Mount Desert Island & Acadia National Park) Nora Roberts Three Sisters Island CD Collection: Dance Upon the Air, Heaven and Earth, Face the Fire (Three Sisters Island Trilogy) Island Of Hope: The Story of Ellis Island and the Journey to America Barron's ACT Math and Science Workbook, 2nd Edition (Barron's Act Math & Science Workbook)