

File Size: 1460 KB
Print Length: 411 pages
Publisher: Bloomsbury USA Childrens; 1 edition (February 1, 2011)
Publication Date: February 1, 2011
Sold by: Digital Services LLC
Language: English
ASIN: B004PGMHVK
Text-to-Speech: Enabled
X-Ray: Not Enabled
Word Wise: Enabled
Lending: Not Enabled
Enhanced Typesetting: Enabled
Best Sellers Rank: #810,706 Paid in Kindle Store (See Top 100 Paid in Kindle Store) #31 in Kindle Store > Kindle eBooks > Children's eBooks > Literature & Fiction > Historical Fiction > Renaissance #56 in Books > Teens > Historical Fiction > Renaissance #76 in Kindle Store > Kindle eBooks > Teen & Young Adult > Literature & Fiction > Geography & Cultures > Europe

With all the hundreds of young adult fiction books that are published each year, Mary Hoffman's Stravaganza books still remain my all-time favorite series since I picked up the first installment seven years ago. City of Secrets continues to carry over a high standard mix of quality writing, fabulous characters and thickened multi-layered plots. One warning about this episode, it is not a stand alone story. One must read all three other novels before starting the City of Secrets. Without first reading City of Masks, City of Stars, and City of Flowers, you will be totally clueless and will not understand who is who and what is happening. There are many, many references in this book to events and characters in the previous novels that are key to this story's unfolding. The author has clearly put many years and incredible effort into creating her world of Talia, an alternate world of Italy in the 1500's. Each book is about a different character in a different city state of Talia, cities that correlate to real places we have in Italy today such as Venice, Florence, Siena and Padua. The period detail that Mary Hoffman gives to this series of a glamorous Renaissance Italian world is incredible. Every page a work of art as the reader is totally transported out of the room they are reading in, far away to Talia. The writing is totally evocative of the whole culture in Italy at that time, rich in wealth, and steeped in romance, art, religion and history. These stories are so full of adventure, and are enchanting and exciting.The series is about a group of teenagers in London who all happen to meander into an antique shop. Each picking out a trinket to take home. These selected items become their Talismans in which when the teens fall asleep with them, they are transported to the world of Talia.
This 4th installation of the Stravaganza seriesstarts out as a formulaic snoozer. We meet Matt, yet anotherdisenchanted, teen. His insecurities seemingly stem fromhaving dyslexia.Matt is unlikeable & uninteresting,but then I had a hard time feeling very sympatheticwith the plights of the last 3 Stravaganters,who just seemed drawn in order to preserve Lucian's life making their stories merely backdrops for the Luciano/Arianna storyline. A continued over abundance of political foiling goes on in this book,culminating explosively.I just wish it could have been brought about with less tediousness. Sadly many of the characters are flat props for the story.A troubling recurring instance of the stravaganter totally disconnecting from the real world began to seem like an addiction to me. Thenot sleeping,not doing homework,not relating to anyone not connected to the Stravagating. I began to see the stravagating as life sucking for the stravgator. Those in the alternate universe are definitely a needy lot. There were some troubling ethics in this book.******spoiler alert**************1)Matt puts a serious curse on his girlfriend's ex.and the guy lands in the hospital. What's with the introduction of voodoo witch craft all the sudden?Stravagaters are turning out not to be very ethical.2) Why does Matt's girlfriend of 3 months have his house key ?3) Why don't Matt or his girlfriend's parents have a problem with her staying over night in his room?(they are about 16!)Juxtaposidly, Lucian, has not slept with Arianna, has no intention of doing so, but does intend to marry her as soon a possible. Matt has no intention of marrying his girlfriend...
Ugh. After picking up five exciting books from the library, this was the one I got around to first, because City of Flowers (its immediate predecessor) ended so suspensefully. If City of Flowers was something of a disappointment compared to City of Masks and City of Stars (which remain some of my favorite books of all time, especially Masks!), then City of Secrets was a mega-disappointment.I could spend thousands of words criticizing this book: The writing didn't flow, characters weren't developed very well, Hoffman didn't spend any time exploring the city of Padavia (a.k.a. this world's Padua)...you get the picture. The no-exploration thing probably got my goat the most, because having never been to Italy, these books are kind of like a free, exciting plane ticket. But this one spent way too much time on Matt's insecurities (Ayesha, anyone? Yuck!)Another problem I had with it was my long-abiding love of Lucien Mulholland. I adore Lucien Mulholland. Or Luciano, or whatever the heck you call him. Ditto for Arianna. So even in City of Stars I was a little disappointed that she started introducing new characters with Georgia and Alice, and in City of Flowers, even more so with Sky and Falco. They took time away from the characters I really enjoyed hearing about, even though all four had grown on me by the end of their respective novels. With the intro of Matt and Ayesha, though, it just started getting ridiculous and watered-down. Pretty much very page Luciano and Arianna weren't on was ridiculously boring.Last complaint? Luciano and Arianna, WOULD YOU TWO JUST GET MARRIED, ALREADY? Sheesh. I was really crossing my fingers in this one for a big, fancy, old-school Bellezzan party with lots of Duchessa excess, but unfortunately, it just wasn't so.
Stravaganza: City of Secrets Stravaganza City of Masks Stravaganza City of Stars Stravaganza: City of Flowers Stravaganza: City of Ships My Favorite Shoes: A touch-and-feel shoe-stravaganza Minecraft Secrets: Master Handbook Edition: Top 100 Ultimate Minecraft Secrets You May Have Never Seen Before (Unofficial Minecraft Secrets Guide for Kids) (Ultimate Minecraft Secrets Handbook) Minecraft Secrets Handbook: 101 Ultimate Secrets: The Awesome Minecraft Secrets Handbook for ALL Minecraft Fans: Tips and Tricks That You Need to Know (An Unofficial Minecraft Handbook) MINECRAFT: MINECRAFT SECRETS HANDBOOK: Top 101 Incredible Minecraft Secrets Handbook You Need To Know (Unofficial Minecraft Secrets Guide for Kids) (Ultimate Minecraft Secret Guide Handbooks) Minecraft: Minecraft Secrets Handbook : Master these Ultimate Minecraft game tips, tricks, secrets and hints to take your game to the next level. (Unofficial Minecraft Secrets Guide) White City, Black City: Architecture and War in Tel Aviv and Jaffa (MIT Press) MUSIC CITY NEWS magazine March 1980 George Jones on cover (The Sound of a City Heard Around The World, Volume XVII No. 9, Country Music, Bluegrass Music,) Twin Cities Chef's Table: Extraordinary Recipes from the City of Lakes to the Capital City Kansas City: A Food Biography (Big City Food Biographies) City of Sedition: The History of New York City during the Civil War The Historical Atlas of New York City, Third Edition: A Visual Celebration of 400 Years of New York City's History The Historical Atlas of New York City: A Visual Celebration of 400 Years of New York City's History Storied City: A Children's Book Walking-Tour Guide to New York City StreetSmart NYC Map by VanDam - City Street Map of Manhattan, New York, in 9/11 National Memorial Edition - Laminated folding pocket size city travel and subway map, 2016 Edition Curating Kinshasa: City Notebook For Kinshasa, Democratic Republic of the Congo: A D.I.Y. City Guide In Lists (Curate Your World)