

File Size: 433 KB
Print Length: 196 pages
Publisher: HMH Books for Young Readers (January 3, 2011)
Publication Date: January 3, 2011
Sold by: Digital Services LLC
Language: English
ASIN: B003K16PEQ
Text-to-Speech: Enabled
X-Ray: Enabled
Word Wise: Enabled
Lending: Not Enabled
Enhanced Typesetting: Enabled
Best Sellers Rank: #262,860 Paid in Kindle Store (See Top 100 Paid in Kindle Store) #25 in Kindle Store > Kindle eBooks > Children's eBooks > Geography & Cultures > Multicultural Stories > Native North & South Americans #47 in Kindle Store > Kindle eBooks > Children's eBooks > Literature & Fiction > Historical Fiction > United States > Colonial #227 in Books > Children's Books > Literature & Fiction > Historical Fiction > United States > Colonial

Sequels are almost always a let-down. I loved IotBD in grade school, and was thrilled to discover the sequel -- twenty-five years later, while in the library with kids of my own. I took it home and devoured it, but was left dissatisfied.Not only does Zia's story pale in comparison to Karana's heroic survival, but several moments left me frowning with annoyance.First of all, the plot inconsistencies drove me mad. Midway through the book, we are given to believe that all the young people at the mission have run away, leaving only Karana and some old Indians behind. (This is crucial to the plot, as she alone is blamed by the cruel captain as a suspected accomplice of the runaways.) But then we learn, out of the blue, that her brother has also remained behind -- but we're never told why. Later, when Karana comes to the mission and is given a bed in the girls' sleeping quarters, I thought this room would now be desolate -- but O'Dell tells us it's still crowded. With whom?Sadly too, the character of Karana takes a beating in this book. In IotBD, she was a hero, larger than life. But seen through Zia's eyes, she is a mute and pitiable recluse lost in a foreign world, who takes childish delight in melons. This might be realistic, but it's a pathetic turn of events that I would rather not have read.There is also a tragic irony that runs through the plot, to wit: Karana left her island to seek companionship at long last. But in the sequel, we learn that she ends up withdrawing to an isolated cave where she recreates a tinier, sadder version of her free life on the island, before finally dying of a broken heart.
Zia (Island of the Blue Dolphins Book 2) A Teaching Guide to Island of the Blue Dolphins (Discovering Literature Series) Island of the Blue Dolphins 2014 Calendar: Dolphins: 12-Month Calendar Featuring Fabulous Photographs of Dolphins Dolphins and Sharks: A Nonfiction Companion to Magic Tree House #9: Dolphins at Daybreak (Magic Tree House (R) Fact Tracker) Zia R is for Rhode Island Red: A Rhode Island Alphabet (Discover America State by State) Island: Poetry and History of Chinese Immigrants on Angel Island, 1910-1940 (Naomi B. Pascal Editor's Endowment) Island Passages: An Illustrated History of Jekyll Island, Georgia Acadia: The Complete Guide: Acadia National Park & Mount Desert Island (Acadia the Complete Guide Mount Desert Island & Acadia National Park) Nora Roberts Three Sisters Island CD Collection: Dance Upon the Air, Heaven and Earth, Face the Fire (Three Sisters Island Trilogy) Treasure Seekers: 13 Bible lessons for ages 3-12 about the character of God; tropical island theme with island snacks, activities, fully reproducible (13 Week Bible Curriculum) Island Of Hope: The Story of Ellis Island and the Journey to America Kelley Blue Book Consumer Guide Used Car Edition: Consumer Edition July - September 2016 (Kelley Blue Book Used Car Guide Consumer Edition) Whales and Dolphins Coloring Book (Dover Nature Coloring Book) Blue Lily, Lily Blue: Book 3 of the Raven Cycle Moleskine Volant Journal (Set of 2), Large, Ruled, Powder Blue, Royal Blue, Soft Cover (5 x 8.25) Why Is Blue Dog Blue? Rihanna (Blue Banner Biographies) (Blue Banner Biographies) Vanessa Anne Hudgens (Blue Banner Biographies) (Blue Banner Biographies)